Comparing the Meaningfulness of Finite and Infinite Lives: Can We Reap What We Sow if We Are Immortal?

Abstract On the rise over past 20 years has been ‘moderate supernaturalism’, view that while a meaningful life is possible in world without God or soul, much greater meaning would be only with them. William Lane Craig can read as providing an important argument for version of this view, according to which and soul could our lives have eternal, opposed temporally limited, significance since we then held accountable decisions affecting others’ lives. I present two major objections position. one hand, contend if existed had souls lived forever, then, fact, all turn out same. other maintain that, objection wrong, so moral choices indeed make ultimate difference thereby confer eternal on (only) supernatural realm, not capture aptly by moderate supernaturalists, purely natural world.